Inside Iran, report
Iran's statisticians say the economy shrank 10.1 per cent. The quarter they measured ended in June.
The Statistical Center of Iran reported on Sunday that GDP fell 10.1 per cent year on year in the first quarter of the Persian year, and 4.6 per cent with oil taken out. The count stops on June 20, before the months for which Kpler and Vortexa estimate the lowest Iranian crude loadings.
What we know
- Confirmed
The Statistical Center of Iran reported on Sunday 20 September figures for the first quarter of the Persian year. The release is carried by Tasnim, by Radio Farda, which says it was reported by the Islamic Republic News Agency, IRNA, and by Arab News Pakistan under a Tehran dateline.123
- Claimed
The Statistical Center of Iran says GDP fell 10.1 per cent year on year with oil included and 4.6 per cent with oil excluded. No source read here verifies the figures independently.124
- Claimed
The Statistical Center of Iran says agriculture grew 2.3 per cent, industries and mining fell 14.7 per cent and services fell 4.8 per cent.12
- Claimed
Al Jazeera and Firstpost, relaying the official data, put the fall in crude oil and natural gas activity at 26.4 per cent. The figure does not appear in the Tasnim or Radio Farda reports.45
- Confirmed
The quarter ran from March 21 to June 20. The war began with US and Israeli strikes on Iran on February 28.54
- Confirmed
Firstpost reports that the Center “did not explicitly attribute the contraction to the war”. Tasnim’s relay of the release names no cause.51
- Disputed
Tasnim prints GDP with oil as 21,795 against 24,255 a year earlier in thousands of billions of rials. Radio Farda prints the same two numbers in billions of rials. The Center’s own table would settle it and was not read.12
- Claimed
Al Jazeera, citing estimates from Kpler and Vortexa, says Iranian crude and condensate loadings fell from about two million barrels per day in March to roughly 740,000 in July and 220,000-255,000 in August.4
What we don’t know
- What the Statistical Center’s own quarterly table says. Its portal did not load for this desk on 21 September, and every report read here relays the same government dataset.
- Whether the absolute GDP values are in billions or thousands of billions of rials.
- How much of the fall the war caused. The release as relayed separates nothing between strikes, blockade, sanctions, inflation and the currency.
- Where in the Center’s tables the 26.4 per cent oil and gas figure sits. It is absent from the two Persian-language relays read here.
- Whether Radio Farda’s inflation figure of about 80 per cent and Al Jazeera’s 12-month average of 69.9 per cent measure the same thing.
- Anything about the economy after June 20, and when the Center will publish its accounts for the summer quarter.
- Whether any independent estimate exists for the same quarter. None appears in the sources read.
This is a government counting its own economy. Al Jazeera calls the Center “government-administered”.4 Tasnim, the Iranian agency, says the detailed tables sit on the national statistics portal.1 This desk could not open that portal. What follows is the Center’s release as five outlets relay it, and that makes one dataset, not five confirmations.
What the Center counted
The levels behind the percentage come with a wrinkle. Tasnim prints GDP with oil, at constant prices of the Persian year 1400, as 21,795 against 24,255 a year earlier, in thousands of billions of rials.1 Radio Farda, which says the Center’s report was carried by the Islamic Republic News Agency, IRNA, prints the same two numbers in billions of rials.2 The digits agree. The units are a factor of a thousand apart, and the table that would settle it is the one not read here.
Tasnim’s headline puts growth for spring 1405 at minus 4 per cent. The line directly beneath it gives minus 10.1 with oil and minus 4.6 without.1 Four is neither of them.
What the number does not say
Firstpost opens by writing that the war “hit oil production, industry and economic activity”. Further down it notes that the Center “did not explicitly attribute the contraction to the war”.5 Tasnim’s relay of the release names no cause at all.1 The figures fix the timing. They do not apportion the fall between the war and what Firstpost lists as problems Iran already had: US sanctions, a weakening rial and high inflation.5
The numbers around the release are each the work of whoever counted them. Al Jazeera puts 12-month average inflation at 69.9 per cent earlier this month, official unemployment at 9.1 per cent in the spring, and the rial at more than 2.2 million to the dollar in early September, against about one million a year earlier.4 Radio Farda puts inflation at about 80 per cent on the latest announced statistics and does not name the measure.2 President Masoud Pezeshkian said on September 6 that total trade had fallen by 25 to 35 per cent, imports harder than exports.4
After June 20
Al Jazeera, citing estimates from Kpler and Vortexa, says Iranian crude and condensate loadings fell from about two million barrels per day in March to roughly 740,000 in July and 220,000-255,000 in August.4 July and August lie outside the quarter the Center measured. Firstpost makes the same point from the other side: the figures cover only the first quarter, and what they mean for the year depends on the quarters that follow.5
Chris Beauchamp, a market analyst at IG Group, told Al Jazeera the drop “is a sign that the US is succeeding in putting pressure on its foe”. The question, he said, is “whether Iran can weather the fall in economic activity better than the US can stand the surge in energy costs”.4 Iran’s security chief, Mohsen Rezaei, told Al Jazeera on Saturday that Tehran’s conditions for ending the war include “the release of our frozen funds and an end to the naval blockade”.4
Keep the evidence open.
This will change. We will tell you when.
Sources
- رشد اقتصادی کشور در بهار 1405 منفی 4 درصد شد
- مرکز آمار ایران رشد اقتصادی سه ماه اول امسال را «منفی ۱۰.۱ درصد» اعلام کرد
- Iran GDP falls more than 10 percent in Mideast war: official statistics
- How oil, gas losses have shrunk Iran’s GDP by 10 percent during war
- Iran economy shrinks 10.1% during US-Israel war, official data shows
Corrections and updates
No corrections have been made to this report.
Seen an error? Write to corrections@ww3.press. Our corrections policy explains what happens next.